Jurisdiction
Not every charge laid in Frankston is finished in Frankston
Which court hears your matter decides how long it takes, who decides it, and the maximum sentence available. It is set by the section number on your charge sheet.
Victorian criminal offences fall into three practical groups, and the group yours belongs to has more effect on your life over the next year than almost anything else about the charge. It determines whether your matter is over in four months or eighteen, whether a magistrate or a jury decides it, and what the court is allowed to do at the end.
People routinely guess this from the name of the offence and get it wrong. Theft sounds minor and is indictable. Contravening an intervention order sounds procedural and carries imprisonment. The only reliable guide is the section number printed next to each charge on the sheet you were given.
The three groups
01
Summary offences
Frankston Magistrates' Court, start to finish
The bulk of the criminal list. Most driving and traffic offences, lower level assaults, most theft and shop theft, property damage, offensive behaviour, breaches of intervention orders and most drug possession charges. A magistrate hears them, there is no jury, and the matter is normally finished within months rather than years.
02
Indictable offences that can be heard summarily
Usually Frankston, if you consent and the court agrees
A large middle category, including many charges of theft, burglary, obtaining property by deception, and a range of assault and drug charges. These are technically indictable but the law allows a magistrate to hear them if the court considers it appropriate and the accused consents. It is a decision worth making with advice, because it trades a jury for a substantially lower sentencing ceiling and a much faster finish.
03
Straight indictable offences
Committed from Frankston to the County Court or Supreme Court in Melbourne
The most serious charges, including murder, manslaughter, serious sexual offences, armed robbery, and large scale drug trafficking. They begin at Frankston with a committal process, where a magistrate decides whether there is enough evidence to put you on trial. They are then heard by a judge and jury elsewhere, on a timeline measured in a year or more.
What changes when a matter goes to Melbourne
A committal at Frankston can take several months on its own, and a County Court trial date is then set well beyond that. Bail conditions stay in force throughout. Costs rise, because a higher court matter involves a barrister and considerably more preparation. Against that, the process gives you a jury, a full opportunity to test the prosecution case at committal, and in a serious matter those are worth having.
What that means practically is that the first few weeks of a serious charge matter disproportionately. Decisions made at the first mention, before the brief has landed, can shape a matter that will still be running in two years’ time. If your charge sheet includes anything from the third group, get advice before your first appearance rather than after it.
For what the Magistrates’ Court can do at the end of a summary matter, see sentencing outcomes. For the day itself, see Frankston Magistrates’ Court.
Bring the charge sheet. Free initial conference for most matters.
Common questions
Charges and jurisdiction
How do I know whether my charge is summary or indictable?
The charge sheet names the Act and the section for each charge, and that is what determines the category. Offences under the Summary Offences Act 1966 are summary. Offences under the Crimes Act 1958 are usually indictable, but many of them can still be heard summarily. The safest approach is not to work it out from the offence name, which can be misleading, but to have someone read the section numbers on the sheet.
Should I agree to have an indictable charge heard in the Magistrates' Court?
Usually, but not always. The advantages are large: a lower maximum sentence, a much shorter wait, lower cost, and no jury. The disadvantage is that you give up a jury trial, which in a small number of cases is genuinely where a matter is best fought. It is one of the few decisions in a criminal matter that is difficult to undo, so it should be made after the brief has been read rather than at a first mention.
What is a committal hearing?
It is the process by which a Magistrates' Court decides whether the prosecution's evidence is capable of supporting a conviction on an indictable charge, and therefore whether the accused should stand trial in a higher court. It also serves a practical purpose for the defence: it is often the only opportunity to cross examine key prosecution witnesses before trial, which can shape everything that follows.
Can a charge be moved between courts later?
It can change category during a matter, most often because the prosecution amends the charges, or because the court decides an indictable charge is or is not suitable to be heard summarily. It is another reason the charges you were originally given are not necessarily the charges you will end up answering.
Read next
Frankston Magistrates' Court
Where it is, what time to get there, which courtroom, and what actually happens on a mention day.
The contest mention
The hearing that decides whether your matter runs as a contest or resolves. Most matters end here.
Sentencing outcomes
Diversion, a good behaviour bond, a fine, a community corrections order, and what a conviction means.
