The end of the matter
What a magistrate can actually do at the end
Sentencing is a smaller menu than people expect, and the argument that matters most is usually not about the penalty. It is about whether a conviction is recorded.
Almost everyone facing a criminal charge asks the same question first, which is whether they are going to gaol. For the overwhelming majority of matters heard at Frankston Magistrates’ Court, the answer is no. Imprisonment is a sentence of last resort under Victorian law and a court has to be satisfied that nothing else will do.
The question that matters far more often, and gets asked far less, is whether a conviction will be recorded. A conviction is what shows up on a police check. It is what affects a working with children check, a security licence, a professional registration, and travel to some countries. A fine with no conviction and a fine with a conviction are the same money and completely different consequences.
The court has a discretion about that, and it is one of the few things on the day that is genuinely responsive to preparation.
The available outcomes, roughly least to most serious
Diversion
No finding of guilt, no convictionThe best available outcome, and the one most worth asking about early. If the prosecution agrees to recommend diversion and the court grants it, you complete conditions (often a donation, a letter of apology, a course) and the charge is discharged with no finding of guilt at all. It is not available for every offence, and the prosecution has to be on board, which is why raising it before the first mention is far more useful than raising it at a plea.
Adjourned undertaking, with or without conviction
Court's discretionCommonly called a good behaviour bond. The court adjourns the matter for a period, up to five years, on your undertaking to be of good behaviour and to comply with any conditions. If you comply, nothing further happens. A magistrate can impose one with a conviction recorded or without, and that distinction is often the whole argument on the day.
Fine
Court's discretionA financial penalty, which can also be imposed with or without a conviction. The court must consider your capacity to pay, and payment arrangements can be sought. A fine on its own does not create a criminal record unless a conviction is recorded alongside it.
Community corrections order
Court's discretionA supervised order served in the community. It always carries a condition not to reoffend and can add unpaid community work, supervision, treatment for alcohol, drugs or mental health, curfews, and exclusion conditions. It is a serious order and a genuine alternative to imprisonment, but it is also demanding, and breaching it brings the matter back to court for resentencing on the original offence.
Imprisonment
Conviction recordedThe sentence of last resort. A Victorian court must not impose imprisonment unless it is satisfied no other sentence is appropriate. In the Magistrates' Court a term can be combined with a community corrections order in some circumstances. The material put before the court on a plea is what most often makes the difference here.
Where sentencing gets decided
Two earlier points in the process have more influence on sentence than the plea hearing itself. The first is jurisdiction: an indictable charge heard summarily carries a far lower ceiling than the same charge in the County Court, which we cover in which court hears your charge.
The second is the contest mention, where charges are narrowed and the facts the court will sentence on are agreed. Being sentenced on a shorter set of facts is often worth more than any submission made afterwards.
Free initial conference for most matters.
Common questions
Sentencing
Is a community corrections order a conviction?
Not necessarily. A community corrections order can be imposed with a conviction recorded or without one. The order and the conviction are two separate decisions the magistrate makes, and the second is argued separately. Whether a conviction is recorded turns on the seriousness of the offence, your history, and the effect a conviction would have on your employment and prospects, which is evidence you have to actually put before the court.
What happens if I breach a community corrections order?
Breaching the order is itself an offence, and the original matter comes back to court to be dealt with again. The court can confirm the order, vary it, cancel it and resentence you on the original offence, or in a serious breach impose a term of imprisonment. If you cannot comply with a condition, the right move is to raise it with corrections and get the order varied before it becomes a breach.
How do I get diversion?
The prosecution has to recommend it and the court has to grant it. It is available where the offence is not one carrying a minimum or fixed sentence, you acknowledge responsibility, and diversion is in the interests of you and the community. In practice the work is in persuading the informant early, before positions harden, with material about your circumstances and what you have already done. It is the single strongest argument for getting advice before your first appearance rather than after it.
Can I ask the court not to record a conviction?
Yes, and you should, wherever it is realistically available. Victorian law requires a court to consider the nature of the offence, your character and history, and the effect a conviction would have on your economic or social wellbeing and on your employment prospects. That last part is only persuasive if there is evidence of it in front of the magistrate: a letter from an employer, a licensing requirement, a course you are enrolled in.
Read next
The contest mention
The hearing that decides whether your matter runs as a contest or resolves. Most matters end here.
Which court hears your charge
Summary, indictable, and indictable triable summarily. Why some Frankston matters end up in Melbourne.
Frankston Magistrates' Court
Where it is, what time to get there, which courtroom, and what actually happens on a mention day.
