The Criminal Law Division of Bayside Solicitors, Frankston. Same firm, same office at 36 Dandenong Road West. For the firm's other practice areas, visit baysidesolicitors.net.au.

Stage four of five

The contest mention is where most matters actually end

It has the least memorable name of any hearing in the Magistrates’ Court and it is the one that most often decides the outcome.

If you pleaded not guilty at your first mention, the next date on your paperwork is probably a contest mention. The name is unhelpful. It sounds like a contested hearing and it is close to the opposite of one: nobody gives evidence, no witnesses attend, and the magistrate makes no finding about whether you did it.

What the day is for is narrowing. A magistrate sits with the prosecutor and the defence and works out what is genuinely in dispute, whether it can be resolved, and if not, how much court time a contested hearing would need. It exists because a court cannot list every not guilty plea for a full hearing, and because a great many not guilty pleas turn out, once the brief has been read, to be arguments about one charge or one paragraph of the facts rather than about the whole matter.

The practical consequence is that the contest mention is a real opportunity and a real risk. Matters resolve there on better terms than they would after a contested hearing, because the prosecution has an incentive to settle before witnesses are summonsed. Matters also resolve badly there, when someone unprepared accepts the first thing offered in a corridor.

How the day runs

  1. 01

    Before the day: the brief and the negotiation

    By the contest mention your lawyer should have the full brief of evidence and should already have written to the informant about which charges are in dispute and why. The best contest mentions are ones where most of the work happened in the fortnight before, not in the corridor outside.

  2. 02

    The corridor conversation

    Before the matter is called, your lawyer speaks to the prosecutor about what could resolve it. Charges being withdrawn, a charge being replaced with a less serious one, or an agreed set of facts that removes the aggravating detail. If both sides can agree, the rest of the morning is short.

  3. 03

    In front of the magistrate

    The magistrate is not deciding guilt. They are asking what the real issue is, whether it can be narrowed, and how long a contested hearing would take. Magistrates at a contest mention will often give a frank indication of how the evidence looks, and sometimes an indication of the likely sentencing range if the matter resolved that day.

  4. 04

    It resolves, or it gets a date

    If it resolves, the matter is usually pleaded and sentenced immediately or shortly afterwards. If it does not, the court sets a contested hearing date, fixes how long it will run, and identifies which prosecution witnesses have to attend so they can be summonsed. That witness list matters: a witness nobody required to attend is a witness who will not be cross examined.

What to bring, and what to have ready

If there is any prospect of the matter resolving, the material that supports a plea should already exist by the contest mention: character references, evidence of counselling or treatment, proof of employment, anything showing steps taken since the charge. The reason is simple. If the matter resolves at 10am, the plea may be heard at 11am, and you cannot go home and collect a reference in between.

This is also the point at which it is worth being honest with yourself about what the brief shows. A contested hearing you lose costs you the discount a plea of guilty would have attracted. A contested hearing you win costs you nothing but the wait. The decision belongs to you, but it should be made against the evidence rather than against a hope.

Call (03) 9781 4822

Free initial conference for most matters.

Common questions

Contest mentions

What is a contest mention in the Magistrates' Court?

It is a hearing listed after you have pleaded not guilty, where a magistrate examines whether the matter can be resolved without a full contested hearing. No witnesses give evidence and no finding of guilt is made. The magistrate identifies what is genuinely in dispute, encourages the parties to narrow it, and if it cannot be resolved, sets the contested hearing down with a time estimate and a witness list.

What happens after a contest mention?

One of two things. Either the matter resolves, in which case it moves to a plea and sentence, often on the same day or a date soon after, or it does not, in which case the court fixes a contested hearing date. A contested hearing is typically listed some months later, because the court has to find a day long enough for the witnesses to be heard.

Do I have to attend the contest mention?

Yes, in the ordinary course. The court expects you there and the whole point of the day is that decisions may be made, including a plea being entered and a sentence being imposed. If you are not present, your lawyer cannot take instructions on an offer that only stands that morning, which is exactly the situation the day is designed to create.

Can charges be dropped at a contest mention?

They can, and they often are, in whole or in part. A contest mention is the natural point for the prosecution to review what it can actually prove now that the brief is complete and the defence has said what is disputed. Charges get withdrawn, downgraded, or replaced with an agreed statement of facts. That is not a technicality, it is the process working the way it is meant to.